Site practice

MEP Coordination & Clash Detection

Every service needs space: ducts, pipes, drains, sprinklers, cable trays and lights all compete for the same ceiling void. Coordination decides who goes where before anything is installed, so the site doesn't discover the clash with a grinder.

Priorities in the void

  • Gravity drainage first: it can't go uphill and needs a fixed fall.
  • Then the largest ducts, which are hardest to reroute.
  • Then pressurised pipes (CHW, water, sprinkler mains), then cable trays and busways, then small services.
  • Keep access zones for valves, dampers, VAV boxes and pull boxes, and the clearances the codes and makers require (e.g. around sprinkler heads and electrical panels).

Combined services drawings and models

  • Each discipline models its services; the federated model brings them together with structure and architecture.
  • Clash detection (e.g. Navisworks, Solibri, BIM Collaborate) finds hard clashes (two objects in the same place), soft clashes (clearance zones) and workflow clashes (sequence).
  • Combined services drawings (CSD) and sections at critical zones are signed by all trades before shop drawings.
  • Builder's work openings, sleeves and beam penetrations are agreed with the structural engineer early.

Running coordination meetings

  • Work by level and zone, with the model on screen and a clash log.
  • Each clash gets a proposed solution, an owner and a target date.
  • Decisions that change the design go back to the designer as an RFI.
  • Close the zone with a signed CSD before releasing it for installation.

Typical clash types

TypeExample
HardDuct runs through a beam
Soft (clearance)Cable tray within the access space of a fire damper
Workflow / sequenceCeiling grid installed before the sprinkler test
Data / duplicateTwo copies of the same pipe in the model
Good to knowModel the hangers and insulation, not just the pipe and duct centre lines. Most 'surprise' clashes on site are insulation and supports nobody drew.

Use with this guide

Found an error? Tell us

Describe the problem briefly (the wrong value, the right one, and the reference if you have it). The page name is sent automatically.